Can I call myself the extractor expert on the forum ? Can I ??? Can I ??? :laugh:
My personal opinions:
- Durrmaid 1600: An awesome little carpet extractor. It has an on-board heater, and a good amount of water lift. It is very compact, this is the best feature of this unit for anyone who's a mobile detailer or has very limited shop / garage space. You have to be a bit careful, there are no pressure safety options with this unit.... If you leave the machine running without releasing pressure through the sprayer for long enough (about 2 to 3 minutes), the pump will burn out. That said, Dennis Durr, the owner / operator of the company that manufactures these extractors, is a great guy and very easy to get ahold of. He has replacement parts in stock at all times, and ships them very quickly if something does happen to you. I've gone through 3 pumps and he's replaced them all under warranty, doesn't charge me for shipping either, and has never requested that I send the old one back. The Durrmaid is also well priced, you can get it for around $650 USD.
- Mytee Lite-II 8070: This is a bigger unit when compared to the Durrmaid. The heater and water lift are very similar though. In real world usage, the Mytee seems to be built a bit better quality wise, and has held up to more abuse than the Durrmaid has. The heater does work better, as it's an "in-line" heater, heating only what's moving through the line vs the Durrmaid's coil heater that heats the entire solution tank. No parts have gone on me so for on the Mytee (fingers crossed), and it's been through a lot of use (minimum 1.5 hours a day on a standard 5 day work week). MSRP is $899 USD, you can find it for around $850 USD on various sites.
- Mytee HP60: Simply a bigger version of the Lite-II 8070, with better water lift and a higher wattage heater. MSRP is $1449 USD, I've seen it for sale for $1300 USD. Honestly (and I own both), if you're doing a LOT of volume and you need uber-fast drying times, I can't really recommend this one over the Lite-II 8070, simply based on the cost factor. Soiling can be gotten out just the same with a little brushing and agitation of the carpets prior to extracting, so basically all you're really doing is being able to get more water lift, which allows the carpets to dry faster. In short, this HP60 saves you time over the Lite-II 8070.
- Bissel LGM: I used this while I was waiting for a replacement pump for the Durrmaid. This machine cost $99 at Wal-Mart. With that in mind, understand that the general basic rule of consumer goods applies here, you get what you pay for. The water lift isn't very good, small rocks, stones and debris won't get lifted (where those things will with all the above extractors). Now before you say "well sure, but just vacuum first", anyone who has experienced things like sand in an interior will understand what I'm talking about. An extractor should be able to pick up small, loose debris without any issue. The LGM has very serious problems with this. The tanks are very small as well, expect to be refilling and emptying the tanks once or twice per vehicle. If you go for the cheaper model, there is no on-board water heater, so you need to have access to a hot water tap. Even on the heated model, the heater does not get very hot, and it takes a long time. I would only recommend the LGM as a backup unit, or if you really only need it like once every 3 months.
I find this topic always to be interesting on this forum. Professional detailers will buy a PC or Flex or Makita polisher for hundreds of dollars. If I said I was going to buy this Simoniz polisher:
Simoniz Orbital Car Polisher | Canadian Tire for professional paint corrections, I'd probably get flogged by every experienced person here. Essentially, you're talking about doing the exact same thing with an extractor. Don't cheap out and get something like the LGM or some $150 steamer. If you're going to work on carpets and upholstery, get a real, quality extractor that's made for professionals.