COBRyan,
I found that experiment to be quite interesting and the superficial appearance of the final solidified product appears quite normal. I did take note that Chris did stir his mixture (wood spoon) and if he did so during the whole process no macrostratification would be noted.
Two key points not discussed or analyzed. A cross-sectioning of the "new" product was not performed to look for stratification or product mottling.
Second, how were the volatile components re-constituted back into the formulation. These volatile components easily evaporate at normal ambient temperature (this is why a carnuaba mixture dries when applied to finish).
If these volatile components are "not" required in either of these formulations, Chris's experiment just discovered how Meg and other VOC non-compliant products can be re-introduced simply by evaporating off this component if this new admixture minus VOC's is as easy to use, durable as parent products and offer the same or better appearance enhancements.
Chris made a big mistake by going public.
Obviously, this is not the case and elimination of VOC's and maintaining original integrity is not that simple.
Where's Mr. Chemist (Mother's) when you need him.
Interesting discussion and experiment though. :xyxthumbs