AOI/SG vs NXT on the same car.

S

Scottwax

New member
I had used Klasse AIO/SG on this black BMW 740iL about 6 weeks ago. I then decided to try NXT on this same car 6 weeks later. No prep was needed, just applied NXT.



I tried to get the angle and hopefully the sunlight the same, but when it was 6 week prior that I took the first picture, it is hard to remember exactly how the car was angled. Anyway, both days were sunny, so the light was similar...at least as close as I could get it for not being in control of sunshine.



AIO/SG:



8781998_bmw740_klasse_sgv2.jpg




6 weeks later, NXT only:



8781998_bmw_740_sg_nxt.jpg




The NXT version looks slightly 'blacker' to me, but that could be the amount of sunlight as much as it is the product. Just shows how hard before and after can be.
 
Looks awesome!



Great comparison photos. It'll definitely take some looking hard at to see a difference, but I do see what you are talking about as far as NXT giving the BMW a slightly black look.



From all the reviews, I will definitely have to give NXT a try......unfortunately! I'm already broke as it is!!!!!:D
 
Here are two more shots for additional comparison. As you can see, the angle does make a difference in how black it looks with the AIO/SG version, less so with NXT.



AIO/SG:



8781998_bmw740_klasse_sg.jpg




NXT:



8781998_bmw_740_sg_nxtv2.jpg
 
The hood and front look the same, but look at the side. The NXT side does seem glossier/wetter, though the SG reflection looks a bit sharper (though that may have to do with positioning also).
 
I'm still in shock here. If this NXT is rivaling some of the best products that we have in our arsenals, but I can go down to the corner store and pick it up right next to something like "nu finish" the supposed once a year car wax, then I'm gonna have to rethink my detailing process and products...:nixweiss
 
Don't sell all your Klasse just yet. Last time I checked SG was only 5 bucks more expensive than NXT. I'll bet I can get far more coats out of a bottle of SG than NXT too. I know for a fact I can get at least 40 coats out of a bottle.



So are you saying that you didn't remove the SG before you applied the NXT? I'm curious to know how this showed us truely how NXT compares to SG on the same vehicle. It looks to me like its showing how good NXT looks on top of SG. :nixweiss
 
Jngrbrdman said:
Don't sell all your Klasse just yet. Last time I checked SG was only 5 bucks more expensive than NXT. I'll bet I can get far more coats out of a bottle of SG than NXT too. I know for a fact I can get at least 40 coats out of a bottle.
Click to expand...



Based on how much of the bottle I have used so far, I am guessing I can get a good 25 applications per bottle-and that does include all the behemoth SUVs and F250s I do.



So are you saying that you didn't remove the SG before you applied the NXT? I'm curious to know how this showed us truely how NXT compares to SG on the same vehicle. It looks to me like its showing how good NXT looks on top of SG. :nixweiss
Click to expand...



First off, it had been 6 full weeks since I had used AIO/SG when I used NXT. Second, both pics of each combination were taken right after using that product. The pics of the car with AIO/SG were taken when I initially applied them not 6 weeks later just before using NXT. I could have prepped the paint by using Vanilla Moose or Meguiars #81 (which should have removed the AIO/SG, right?) but since I was doing this out of the goodness of my heart (and he did give me a $75 tip for Christmas) to test how NXT looked on black with no prep, I didn't. I do have a feeling that using a glaze under NXT probably would have made the car look even better than just applying NXT over AIO/SG applied 6 weeks prior.



Was that a completely fair comparison? It was as close as I could get given the circumstances. Is this conclusive proof that NXT is better than AIO/SG? No, of course not. I still don't know how durable NXT is for example. Nor do I know how long it's 'look' holds up. I never drew any conclusive conclusions because the lighting and angles are not 100% equal. All I said was the NXT car looked slightly blacker to me...then mentioned the lighting and angle of the car may have something to do with it.



BTW, just FYI....AIO+NXT on single stage white = teh win. ;)
 
Thanks Scott for sharing this experiment with us. As usual cars look great. :bow

Do you plan any topper experiments: CMW? Natty? P21S/S100?

Have you used Clearkote QS over NXT yet? I love the results I am getting with black ( UPP,NXT and QD'd with FD).



Scott have you notice that the NXT finish is smear resistant.:nixweiss

After curing for 24 hrs if one wipes his/her dry finger across the surface that there is absolutely zero smudging. Incredible. :D
 
blkZ28Conv said:
Thanks Scott for sharing this experiment with us. As usually cars look great. :bow

Do you plan any topper experiments: CMW? Natty? P21S/S100?

Have you used Clearkote QS over NXT yet? I love the results I am getting with black ( UPP,NXT and QD'd with FD).
Click to expand...



This is a newbie question. What improvements would you expect with a topper? It appears to have a deep, wet shine.



The car looks awesome. :up
 
Good question txz28,

Yes, NXT has an excellent final appearance by itself. So much so that the "mad scientist" in me has not emerged to do some topper experiments.

Nevertheless, sometimes a topper increases depth and fills some surface marring uneffected by previous protectant (i.e. NXT, Klasse, UPP, and less so EX( has carnuaba in its formulation :xyxthumbs), etc). Carnaubas are great for their short term filling ability.

Hope this helps. :wavey
 
Nice work Scottwax! I was a little skepetical about NXT, I also felt people were getting a little worked up about it, but it seems like a REALLY great product. I was originally gonna do Mother's Pre-Wax cleaner then #26 for friends and family cars but i think im just gonna wait for NXT to hit shelves and try that. NXT got some good reviews and every picture and review says and show it brings more color which is awesome. I think this product is really going to put Meguiars over the top concerning consumer/professional detailers. It will really connect the bridge of Gold Class wit their Professional series. I am pretty excited that its gonna be in stores making it easy for me to buy, the only thing that angers me is that its easily accessible for other people. I would like to make other people's cars look good, its just that once the secret is out everyone will know where to go. I like to be the only person in town to have a product, but wit NXT coming out i'd have to "hide" all the waxes in all the stores lol.
 
JohnnyDaJackal-I wouldn't worry about the average person using NXT and achieving the results we do. They are just going to slap on some NXT with zero prep. NXT has some light filling ability, but not enough to make up for the average person's swirled and scratched paint.
 
blkZ28Conv said:
Thanks Scott for sharing this experiment with us. As usually cars look great. :bow

Do you plan any topper experiments: CMW? Natty? P21S/S100?

Have you used Clearkote QS over NXT yet? I love the results I am getting with black ( UPP,NXT and QD'd with FD).
Click to expand...



Negative ghostrider. No time right now. On the crappy days, it is either too cold or wet to do anything and on the nice days, I am working past sundown. Maybe in a month or so when the days are longer and warmer.



Scott have you notice that the NXT finish is smear resistant.:nixweiss

After curing for 24 hrs if one wipes his/her dry finger across the surface that there is absolutely zero smudging. Incredible. :D
Click to expand...



Yes, I have noticed that, especially since after using NXT on my car, my customers run their hands across my paint to see how slick it is.
 
grt1today said:
So is your wettest combo still vanilla moose/cmw, or is it blank/nxt???
Click to expand...



VM/CMW is wetter looking, but VM, AIO, CCC (an American Shine glaze) with NXT is still prettty wet and deep looking with somewhat sharper reflections. Not enough of a difference to dump one for the other.
 
Scott,



I know the lighting is not the same in the pics, but on the AIO/SG pics the paint seems look a little clearer than w/ the NXT. Did you find this to be true or is it just a factor of the light, angle, and camara? Great work and thanks for the pics!



Eric B.
 
esbrown1 said:
Scott,



I know the lighting is not the same in the pics, but on the AIO/SG pics the paint seems look a little clearer than w/ the NXT. Did you find this to be true or is it just a factor of the light, angle, and camara? Great work and thanks for the pics!



Eric B.
Click to expand...



That is what I thought too! Looks like the NXT does not give as clear of a reflection???
 
There are too many variables for this to be considered accurate in any meaningful way. The light variations alone mean the photos cannot be fairly compared. The photos were taken on different days at a different time in the day and the sun's position in the sky is now different after 6 weeks of the earth rotating, so the angle of the light hitting is different. Also have a look at how much the bricks in the background vary between photos.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top