3 Metal Polishes

I

imported_Intel486

New member
Never Dull, Super Shines Metal Madness, and Blue Magic's Metal Polish.



I had a chance to test out three different metal polishes today. I was working on some Aluminun Rims. I believe he said they were Eagles. It is on a guys truck. He has a 12" lift... or maybe it is a 15" lift? Not sure but he has 42" tires. I've got a pic of our trucks lined up and his at the end that I'll post later.



First was Never Dull. It worked great! I also love how you just pull that stuff out of the can and can polish with it. You don't have to have a rag to pour it onto to polish.



Next was Super Shine's Metal Madness. Now, this was my least favorite out of the group. It didn't seem to do as good of a job as the others and you had to work it in pretty well. I also was somewhat difficult to completely buff off.



The last I tried was Blue Magic's Metal Polish. It worked great! One of the guys there said it only worked on cold rims. Good thing the guy's rims were cold. It went on easily and seemed to work pretty quickly.



Now, if I had to rate them it would be Never Dull, Blue Magic, and then Metal Madness.



I have a few pictures I'll load off my camera later and post.



I plan on getting Wenol and Mother's Billet to test out. Got a friend with some wenol so hopefully he'll make it out next time so I can try it. I'll wait till I see Mother's Billet locally and grab a can. Right now I'll just continue to carry Never Dull.
 
I tried Never Dull but I like 3M Mag and Aluminum Polish better. Never Dull didn't get my aluminum wheels as bright as 3M did. 3M was more work to clean up the residue but the results were worth the effort. I bought some Wenol last Fall but I won't get around to using it until Spring when I get my aluminum wheels ready to put back on my car.
 
HellrotCi said:
I tried Never Dull but I like 3M Mag and Aluminum Polish better. Never Dull didn't get my aluminum wheels as bright as 3M did. 3M was more work to clean up the residue but the results were worth the effort. I bought some Wenol last Fall but I won't get around to using it until Spring when I get my aluminum wheels ready to put back on my car.
Click to expand...



I might try to find some of the 3m polish then to test out.



I believe West Marine here carries a good amount of 3m stuff. I'll have to stop in to see if they have it.
 
I prefer the Blue Magic cream polish for the initial polish then a follow up with Never Dull wadding polish. The Blue Magic seems just a bit stronger to me in terms of cleaning ability and I paid about $12 for a 19 ounce tub, thats a lot of metal polish....



I'll be waiting for the review on Wenol and Mother's Billet polish.
 
Here are pics.



This is it before.

725-915-47627.jpg




This is the wheel after polishing

725-915-47626.jpg




The big white truck on the end is the one I did the wheels on.

725-915-47631.jpg
 
How easy was NevR-Dull to buff off? I found Metal Madness pretty hard to buff too, although I want to try it on some other stuff to make sure. There are too many polishes out there that aren't hard to buff to put up with the ones that are, IMO.



I didn't think NevR-Dull was safe for use on aluminum. I always figured it was a brass polish like Brasso. Usually brass polishes are too strong for aluminum (and silver), but can be used on practically any other metal (aluminum polishes can be used on brass, they just don't tend to be as strong).



Edit: NevR-Dull is safe on aluminum and silver. And the MSDS is much milder than Brasso's. I guess I'll have to give NevR-Dull a whirl one of these days (though wadding gets your hands pretty yucky).
 
Aurora40 said:
How easy was NevR-Dull to buff off? I found Metal Madness pretty hard to buff too, although I want to try it on some other stuff to make sure. There are too many polishes out there that aren't hard to buff to put up with the ones that are, IMO.
Click to expand...
In my experience, the residue left over from NevR-Dull is easy to wipe off, no real buffing required.



Tort
 
Never-Dull is good stuff I use it to that the soot off my chrome exhaust tips the only thing I dislike about Never-Dull is it makes your hands black and the black is hard to get off your hands
 
Have you tried using a wool buffing ball on a drill with the Metal Madness?



I find it works better than Blue Magic or Mothers which seems to cloud the metal when machined buffed.



The Metal Madness gives a shinier chrome like finish when used by machine more than anything else I've tried.



The creams like wenol and mothers can't take the heat of a buffer and break down too easily, leaving a half done shine.



By the way thanks for the tip on p-11 it works well.
 
Mr. Hicks:

I have seen the wool pads that strap over a backing plate for a drill but not a wool ball. Can you describe this ball? It sounds interesting.



thanks



Sorry for the intrusion on the thread.
 
I too am intersted in the polishing ball and where to find it ?



I ordered some "Metal Madness" today to give it a try. I also ordered a product called "Metal wax" today so I'll give you all an update on that. I'm going to try the "Metal Wax" on my oxidized/stained alum. trailer before I try it on my Weld wheel's.
 
Now that I'm looking at one of my buffs I realize it may not be wool but a heavy cotton fabric.



You can order them at www.swmetal.com



Once on the site go to buffs... click on specialty buffs and your there.



I use a mushroom buff to work in the polish, then after wiping off all the black buildup I take a separate dry finer grade goblet buff and burnish in the oils that have soaked into the metal.



This produces a nearly chrome-like finish.



Metal polishing is different than waxing. With waxing the higest shine is achieved when the wax is wiped off. With metal polishing much of the shine comes after the polish has been wiped off. Good metal polishes have oils and polishes that actually absorb into the metal. Once you wipe off the black grunge you take a separate towel or buff and burnish in these oils to get the highest gloss possible.
 
Stuart,

GOOD FIND !!

Hey thank's for the link on swmetal. That's stuff I've been looking for . I'm going to order a few thing's to try.



Mike
 
I just bought some Blue Magic the other day. I think it was $3 at Pep Boys. Worked great on my exhaust tip, inside and out. I just did the shoe shine method around the outside and a a little blob around the inside and buffed it off.



It was easy, it looks great, and that was the first time I polished my exhaust tip.
 
I love Mothers Billet Polish. It is much better than the standard Mother Aluminum Polish. Its a little more pricey (like $12) but its worth it IMO.
 
Concerning the Never Dull product...



Will it harm newer clear coated aluminum rims? Could you tell me your test results on the quality of the shine? Were you simply happy with the "cleaning power" and easy clean up? And did you observe any micro marring from the Never Dull?
 
Ryan said:
Concerning the Never Dull product...



Will it harm newer clear coated aluminum rims? Could you tell me your test results on the quality of the shine? Were you simply happy with the "cleaning power" and easy clean up? And did you observe any micro marring from the Never Dull?
Click to expand...
I believe NevR-Dull is a metal polish, and not sutable for use on clearcoat . . .



Tort
 
Ryan said:
Concerning the Never Dull product...



Will it harm newer clear coated aluminum rims? Could you tell me your test results on the quality of the shine? Were you simply happy with the "cleaning power" and easy clean up? And did you observe any micro marring from the Never Dull?
Click to expand...



I think Tortoise is right. NevR-Dull probably is not to be used on coated wheels. However, if you are looking for something to use on them, Meguiar's #28 All Metal Polish does say it is "safe and effective on coated and uncoated wheels". It gives an incredible shine, but isn't overly powerful. It might do a good job on embedded brake dust or something, though.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top