Late to this thread: ( very early morning; cannot sleep, look at Autopia Forum on my phone; Oooohh, this is an interesting thread! Typical Captain Obvious response...go figure)
Dan:
Thanks for this brutally honest review and your experience with this particular Sud's Lab car-care product. I am with you about trying an OTC new product, but I generally wait until someone else buys, tries, and reviews it before making the investment of doing so.
Also makes me wonder and question if this product is not that good, is the rest of their products like that. Probably a very bad judgement/assessment on my part by association without a true experience of any of those products by myself, but I think we can all agree it does have an influence on my decision to try a new OTC car-care product line. And like you, Dan, I have "accumulated" ( no offense, Accumulator!) many different products over the years, drawn in by the hype ("flavor of the month"... remember that phrase from way back in this forum?), only to be somewhat disappointed by it/them in our experience, and there they sit on the detailing product shelf, languishing and unused for many years. My regretful "flavor of the month" product purchase?: Presta Chroma 1500 Polish and Strata Ultra Cutting Cream Light, which I paid dearly for from a local distributor. (Yes, had to dig them out from behind the other languishing products on the detailing product shelf in the basement to get their manufacturer and name type correct!)
Works great with a rotary, but I do not have that polishing machine or their Presta pads. Works not-so-great with an older model Porter-Cable Dual-Action orbital and Lake County foam pads.
Used them on a late 1990's BMW 3-series convertible sedan. Looked great in the garage, but not in the sun, despite being waxed with S100 carnauba wax. Still have the pair, thinking SOMEDAY when I get a rotary...still waiting...
Live and learn.